Untitled Document

News Notes
Horses' mouths date Sierra Nevada uplift
Editors' note: This is an expanded version of a story that appeared in print.

Millions of years ago, the Sierra Nevada, the mountain range that forms the eastern boundary of California, spiked from a moderate bump to an extreme crest. While geologists agree that the Sierra Nevada's mountain-building events have been going on for long time, the exact timing of its growth spurt remains controversial. In an effort to pinpoint the escalation, some geoscientists are going straight to the horse's mouth, literally — using horse teeth to date the mountains' uplift.

Estimates on when the Sierra Nevada began its major uplift vary widely. Some volcanic and structural studies place the date between 8 and 5 million years ago, while cave and other geomorphologic studies support very high elevations for the Sierra Nevada (currently over 14,000 feet at its highest) millions of years before then.

The latest study takes advantage of what's known as a "rain shadow": As a cloud moves over a high mountain, it dumps its water as it cools, lifting it up the leeward slope. One way to track this effect millions of years later is through isotope ratios. The first water molecules to drop tend to contain more heavier isotopes, in particular, oxygen-18. Any animals that live on either side of the mountain and drink water will trap the oxygen isotope ratios in their bones and teeth enamel, which scientists can then link to mountain elevations.

Thus, graduate student Brooke Crowley of the University of California at Santa Cruz sampled the tooth enamel — which is less likely to alter than bone, she says — of fossil mammals that lived in the Sierra Nevada mountain range, as well as to the east and west of the mountains. She eventually focused on fossil horse specimens in the University of California at Berkeley collection because horses drink water regularly and were more common in the fossil record than some other large mammals.

Crowley found "a gradient between the isotopes from the west and east; they get very light going east and stay light in the east," she says, a pattern that held for the oldest specimens of horses in the collection, which are 18 million years old. Because storms move from west to east across the Sierra Nevada, that means that enough height had been gained to create a rain shadow (and its one-sided concentration of heavy isotopes) by at least 18 million years ago, Crowley told an audience at the Society of Vertebrate Paleontology annual meeting in Denver, Colo., last November.

Bruce MacFadden, a paleontologist at the Florida Museum of Natural History in Gainesville, says Crowley used "a very innovative technique that's catching on" and "has a lot of potential." The added benefit of using horses, MacFadden says, is that they have evolved into several different forms over time, and thus their fossils provide benchmarks for stratigraphy. The results, he says, rely on the assumption "that weather systems are similar to today."

Indeed, the Nevada region may have had different water sources in the past, Crowley says, and several other variables also could throw off her results, including glacial cycles and past migration patterns. She hopes to test teeth from horses living today for comparison, and will conduct other analyses of her data before she publishes her results.

Naomi Lubick

Click here for the original print version.

Back to top

Untitled Document

Geotimes Home | AGI Home | Information Services | Geoscience Education | Public Policy | Programs | Publications | Careers

© 2018 American Geological Institute. All rights reserved. Any copying, redistribution or retransmission of any of the contents of this service without the express written consent of the American Geological Institute is expressly prohibited. For all electronic copyright requests, visit: