geotimesheader  
Geotimes Home Calendar Classifieds Subscribe Advertise

Geotimes
 Published by the American Geological Institute
Newsmagazine of the Earth Sciences

September 2000


News Notes

Cave confidentiality
 
One of Nature’s most fascinating phenomena is often buried in secrecy. During the National Speleological Society (NSS) Conference 2000, held June 26-30 in Elkins, W. Va., a special presentation devoted to cave exploration featured the ongoing discoveries in the Omega cave system in Virginia. A recently discovered complex cave, Omega Cave, is now the deepest known cave in the eastern United States, reaching 1,260 feet deep and over 10 miles in length. But its discoverers won’t reveal its location — or even the county in which it lies.

Omega Cave is not alone in its secrecy. As an increasing number of people seek to explore caves, many landowners struggle to protect their properties, while cavers strive to gain access.

Access to a cave depends on the number of previous visitors, the organisms and ecosystems in the cave, the presence of endangered species, its geologic features, its beauty, its danger and the owner, says Emily Davis, a volunteer for the NSS and the Northeastern Cave Conservancy (NCC).


   Margaret Palmer gazes at the large gypsum 
   crystals in the Chandelier Ballroom of New 
   Mexico's Lechuguilla Cave. Photos courtesy
   of Arthur Palmer, State University of New York
   at Oneonta.

Cave conservancies now protect newly discovered caves from access because they may have future value. For example, Lechuguilla Cave in New Mexico is home to bacteria not known to exist anywhere else on Earth. Newly discovered caves such as Omega Cave are carefully preserved to “err on the side of caution,” Davis says.

Sometimes both caves and people can become victims of indiscriminate disclosure. Tour guides led visitors along set paths through what was once a “show cave” in New York, she says. But in the late 1960s it fell into disuse and was closed to the public. Still, the cave remained on the old maps and trespassing became a problem.
 

Here, Magaret Palmer stops next to Lechuguilla's
Lake Chandelar, a small lake rimmed with calcite
deposits.
Broken walkways and an 18-foot drop at the cave’s entrance posed dangers. Professional cavers often were called on to rescue hurt or trapped amateurs.  Now the NCC owns the cave and is attempting to rescue it from the beer bottles and broken glass. The society grants permits for timed visits and blocks driving access with large boulders, though some people still sneak through.

But even cavers ask for access limitations at times. Cavers advocate the secrecy to appease landowners and to protect caves. Secrecy stems from a need to protect all involved: potential cavers, cave owners and the cave itself.

Linda Baker Devine of the NSS Board of Governors bought a small cave in West Virginia because, as a caver, she wanted the site open. Now, as a cave owner, her cave has remained open, but she is nervous about the potential for lawsuits from injured cavers. Even though cave laws protect owners from liability claims, owners still face court defense fees. “Liability is the biggest problem,” she says.

The ever-present dangers of caving loom large for both cavers and cave owners. Because of the dangers, the only way to ensure open access to caves is for individual cavers, such as Devine, and cave organizations to purchase them, Devine says.

Purchasing a cave isn’t always an option. Often a small group of cavers communicates with the landowner to set rules for access. Owners sometimes opt to lease parcels of land approaching the cave entrance, thereby shifting responsibility and liability to the renters.

The relationship with an owner is very sensitive, Devine says. Cavers are being especially careful about keeping the Omega cave location secret so no one attempts to trespass on the site. Such an intrusion would ruin the chance of access for all, she says.

Bridget Mulvey



Geotimes Home | AGI Home | Information Services | Geoscience Education | Public Policy | Programs | Publications | Careers

© 2014 American Geological Institute. All rights reserved. Any copying, redistribution or retransmission of any of the contents of this service without the express written consent of the American Geological Institute is expressly prohibited. For all electronic copyright requests, visit: http://www.copyright.com/ccc/do/showConfigurator?WT.mc_id=PubLink